10 First Father’s Day Gifts From Baby That’ll Make Any New Dad Tear Up
This post was created with help from AI tools and carefully reviewed by a human. For more on how we use AI on this site, check out our Editorial Policy.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Additionally, we might earn affiliate commissions from other websites when you click on links and make purchases. This means that whenever you buy a product on Amazon or other affiliated sites from a link on our site, we get a small percentage of its price at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting us!
The first Father’s Day is more than a date on the calendar—it’s a milestone drenched in new-dad wonder, sleep-deprived pride, and the kind of love that hits like a freight train.
Whether the baby is weeks or months old, the right gift can turn that day into a lifelong memory.
These handpicked ideas are sweet, sentimental, and guaranteed to tug at his heartstrings.
10 First Father’s Day Gift Ideas From Baby
1. Custom “Daddy and Me” Storybook
A personalized storybook featuring Dad and Baby as the central characters brings an emotional and heartwarming touch to Father’s Day. These books typically allow you to customize the characters’ names, skin tone, hair color, and even the storyline.
Whether it’s a magical adventure or a day in the life of Dad and Baby, it’s a beautiful way to celebrate their growing bond. This gift becomes a bedtime favorite, a bonding ritual, and a lifelong keepsake.
Where to Get It: Available on websites like Wonderbly or Hooray Heroes.
Price: $35
2. Baby Footprint Art with “My First Hero” Quote
This DIY keepsake captures the delicate size of baby’s feet — a powerful reminder of just how tiny they once were. Framed with a heartfelt message like “My First Hero, My Daddy,” the artwork creates a visual connection between Dad and Baby’s earliest days.
It’s a classic, hands-on project that results in something museum-worthy for Dad’s desk, man cave, or bedside table.
Making Process: Use baby-safe ink or paint to press the baby’s feet onto a canvas. Add a handwritten or vinyl-cut quote and frame it. For added flair, include the date or baby’s name.
Price: Under $20 for materials
3. Matching Custom Outfits – “Dad & Me” Edition
Matching outfits are both practical and adorable. Whether it’s T-shirts with matching slogans like “Big Guy” and “Little Guy” or coordinated loungewear for naptime snuggles, these make for priceless photos and fun Father’s Day memories.
It shows the world (and your camera roll) how in sync Dad and Baby are. These sets can also include onesies, bodysuits, or even caps.
Where to Get It: Custom printed through Etsy or sites like Tees2UrDoor or Amazon.
Price: $30–$45 for both shirts
4. First Father’s Day Memory Jar
This is a sentimental yet super simple gift idea. Fill a decorative jar with notes written from Baby’s perspective — these can be sweet, funny, or imaginative. For example: “Thanks for all the diaper changes!” or “I love your silly songs.”
Add blank notes or prompts for Dad to fill in over the next year — like “Your favorite moment with me today” — turning it into a long-lasting memory capsule. It’s a heartfelt way for Dad to reflect on fatherhood from Day 1.
Making Process: Use a mason jar, decorative paper or cardstock strips, and label it. You can even decorate the jar with paint pens, ribbons, or a custom tag that says “Daddy’s Jar of Love.”
Price: Under $15 for materials
5. Personalized Sound Wave Print of Baby’s Coo or Laugh
There’s something incredibly powerful about a baby’s first coo or giggle. With this idea, you can record a sweet sound from Baby and have it transformed into a piece of modern wall art — a visual soundwave.
Some services even let you add a QR code so Dad can scan it to hear the sound again. This is perfect for first-time dads who want to freeze that fleeting baby stage in a unique and modern format.
Where to Get It: Custom ordered through Etsy or online soundwave art creators like ArtsyVoiceprint.
Price: $40–$60 depending on size and framing
6. “Daddy’s First Handshake” Framed Photo with Baby’s Hand
Capture a photo of Dad holding Baby’s tiny hand — a powerful symbol of protection and love. Print it in black and white, and pair it with a caption like “Our First Handshake” or “From Day One.” Frame it as a timeless piece of wall art or a bedside photo Dad will treasure forever.
Where to Get It: Use your own photo or schedule a mini session with a family photographer, then print and frame it through Shutterfly or a local print shop.
Price: $20–$40 depending on photo and frame
7. Custom Engraved “First Father’s Day” Keychain
A sleek, personalized keychain engraved with a message like “First Father’s Day – 2025” or “Love, [Baby’s Name]” makes for a small but meaningful gift. It’s something Dad can carry every day as a reminder of this milestone year — and it’s perfect for new dads on the go.
Where to Get It: Custom ordered from Etsy, Amazon, or personalization stores like Things Remembered.
Price: $15–$30
8. “Dad’s First Year Survival Kit”
Create a humorous yet practical gift basket filled with essentials for surviving the first year of fatherhood. Include items like earplugs, coffee, energy bars, wipes, and a mini book of “Dad Jokes.” Top it off with a note from Baby: “You’ve got this, Dad!”
Making Process: Use a gift box or basket, fill it with handpicked items, and create custom labels for each one. Add a tag like “Daddy’s Survival Kit – Est. 2025.”
Price: $25–$50 depending on what you include
9. “Letters to My Daddy” Memory Book
Start a memory book with the first “letter” written from Baby to Dad. You can continue to add to it over the years — messages, drawings, and notes marking milestones. The first page could say something like, “Dear Daddy, Even though I can’t talk yet, I already love you so much.”
Making Process: Use a blank journal or purchase a guided memory book. Write the first letter in Baby’s voice, include photos or handprints, and encourage future contributions.
Price: $15–$25
10. Personalized Puzzle with Baby’s Photo
Create a custom jigsaw puzzle using a favorite photo of Dad and Baby together, or even just a solo photo of the baby with a Father’s Day message. Dad can build it during downtime — a creative way to bond and relax, and then frame the finished piece.
Where to Get It: Custom puzzles are available on sites like Shutterfly, Zazzle, or Collage.com.
Price: $25–$35
